Rachel Simmons Chats About Mythbusting “Mean Girl” Media

Aug. 31 2011 Transitioning back to school is tough, especially when media and marketing blitzes the ‘what could be’ fear dynamics of peer acceptance based on what you wear, how you look, and who you sit with at lunch. (Target’s music teacher  ad/video sums in satire well, “if your kids want to sound cool, they need to look cool”)

Now toss in the social media promises and pitfalls of digital angst (and how fast things can ‘go viral’ to do damage in a blink) and you’ve got full blown alarmist anxiety often driven by industry seeding fear in the usual ‘selling insecurity for profit’ modus operandi.

What if we looked at how texting, Facebook and social media could be leveraged by girls, for girls, for good in ‘united we stand’ backtalk?

Look no further than Powered by Girl.org doing ‘makeovers’ on sexploitation ads, SparkSummit.com’s Spark Change revolution, or Miss Representation.org hosting film screenings to combat covert and overt mainstream media portrayal of women as ‘less.’

Even better? Today’s outrage du’ jour using social media to go viral, as Pigtail Pals leads the way to give JCPenney a much-deserved social media thumping for marketing the absurdly dysfunctional anti-academic ‘beauty over brains’ messaging to the younger set. (an all too common flashback to A&F tees like ‘who needs studying when you have these?’ messages or “hooters girl in training’ toddler tees) Owner Melissa Wardy is using social media firepower to instantaneously counter-market this crud with a new tee serving up some sassback to stop this nonsense of lousy corporate values sending toxic messages to kids. (Should be ready by this aft,  social media is a fast-acting must in a toolchest to champion change!) 

I’ll be doing several posts on using social media as an antidote, to engage, inspire, and uplift in a media world that feels almost insistent on using imagery of ‘mean girls,’ relational aggression and social media as a distribution platform to tear people down. Kicking off this series is author Rachel Simmons of the newly updated Odd Girl Out with helpful back to school social media management tips to delete digital abuse and give context to ‘cyberbullying’(bullycides, abusive online behavior etc) vs cyber drama.

Rachel Simmons is not only a best-selling author with pragmatic, real life tips tweens and teens can relate to directly, she’s also founder of the Girls Leadership Institute, is a Rhodes Scholar, and is author of Curse of the Good Girl. 

Her site is a treasure trove of solutions-based thinking and youth voices, joining other anti-bullying favorites of mine like  A Thin Line.org (MTV’s user-driven peer to peer digital literacy site) and That’s Not Cool (apropos for younger kids too) to help mitigate the damage of digital drama.

I’ll also be covering the site Love Is Not Abuse (teen dating/stalking/sexting media literacy)  soon focusing on their new mobile app to educate youth and parents on warning signs…but in our social media conversation with Rachel Simmons today, I’m kicking off the elephant in the living room conundrum…

How can we best put all the anti-bullying ‘businesses’ out of business by NOT “selling abusive conduct” via media in the first place!?

How can industry cut off the IV drip of toxic poison when it’s the very lifeline to their ratings and click through rates?

From TV fall season line-ups to movie plot lines, cartoons, animated webisodes, and kidlit, the stereotyped depiction of a “frenemie” in the mix is as predictable as the rolling credits.

Please welcome Author Rachel Simmons…who I affectionately refer to as “the BFF for the masses.”

Amy Jussel, Shaping Youth:  You note in Odd Girl Out that media now depicts “mean girl” drama on TV at about TEN TIMES the amount of relational aggression existing in real life. With more to “absorb and mimic” then it seems to me media is not just perpetuating, but CREATING problematic behavior by amping up the drama and angst? Your thoughts?

Rachel Simmons: The question of how television influences behavior has been controversial for a long time, and I’m not sure if any specific research examines the impact of reality television on girls’ aggression. (Amy’s note: check out Jenn Pozner’s Reality Bites Back book; a must read!)

That said, here’s what I think “Reality TV” communicates to girls:

1.    Female aggression is funny and entertaining, and therefore a great way to get attention. Attention = celebrity = sense of self-worth and value.
2.    Female aggression is an effective way to get what you want.
3.    Female aggression is always the best strategy when a desired man is involved.

When it is viewed repeatedly in an entertaining format, girls become desensitized to aggression, not unlike what happens when boys blow things up over and over again in a video game.

For boys, a video game is a cartoon, so therefore it’s “not real.” For girls, the aggression is “funny” and “extreme,” so therefore “not real.” But both have a very real impact on kids and teens, especially those who don’t have the media literacy tools to analyze what they’re watching.

Susan Douglas has written at length in her recent book Enlightened Sexism about the insidious way reality television has presented itself as post-feminist while simultaneously being one of the most anti-feminist games in town. It’s one of my must-reads!

Amy Jussel, Shaping Youth: What role can media literacy play to educate the public between “cyberdrama” and cyberbullying? Do you use media clips and current examples in your work to callout digital abuse and drama baiting?

Rachel Simmons: I spend a lot of time observing girls on Facebook and talking with them about the challenges posed by social media.

The examples I use in my presentations are actual texts, status updates or chats that I have personally witnessed.

I also use postings from Formspring, which has surely been the worst offender of the last couple of years. Tumblr is now coming up more often as a platform for cruelty, so I’m using posts from there, too. I’m lucky to have a lot of girls who turn to me when they see things that concern them. My best tips come from the girls.

When I first started speaking about “conventional” bullying and aggression between girls, girls were pretty surprised that any adult even knew what was going on. There was no language or attention paid to the behavior.

I see the same thing happening all over again where social media is concerned: when I call girls out on using their status updates to insult someone publicly, tagging an embarrassing photo, leaving a rude comment or texting in someone’s face, they can’t believe I’m “going there.”

…But I can tell they are also relieved to have a person like me affirm what they all feel inside: this behavior isn’t right, and it should stop. That’s the beginning of change – when something leaves the shadows of personal experience and becomes a collective narrative.

Amy Jussel, Shaping Youth: The anti-bullying flag has been waving wildly in the media, with every school bringing in ‘programs’ that range from pragmatic to patently useless bandwagoning for ‘awareness’…How can schools and orgs best sift out the good ones w/benchmarks and criteria? Tips list?

Rachel Simmons: I use some of the below criteria to assess anti-bullying presenters and programs:

Comprehensiveness – Anyone who thinks one speaker or a single day of awareness will change a school culture is kidding themselves. How comprehensive is the desired program? Does it work with all stakeholders, including parents and school staff (besides teachers), or does it just put the onus on kids to change their behavior? Any anti-bullying program worth its salt will work with all parties within the school structure, and invite them to contribute to the initiative.

Research & Evaluation– Is there any evaluation of the curriculum or program available? For example, the Olweus program is one of the few anti-bullying programs to be rigorously evaluated, so I feel very comfortable recommending it.

Word of Mouth – If you do want to bring in a speaker, how well-regarded is this person? Do some background research and talk to past clients. A speaker can’t change a culture, but they can inspire the first steps. Kids connect to people and their stories. If you don’t have a compelling, authentic, open presenter, it’s tough to connect. You can usually learn pretty fast who’s worth it and who isn’t.

The Messenger – Who is delivering the program? If you send a teacher or counselor who is not trusted or by kids to an anti-bullying training, and then expect that person to lead an initiative, it’s doomed from the start.

Amy Jussel, Shaping Youth: Social media’s influence on sense of self is definitely impacting kids in ‘blessing & a curse’ mode, as you talk about new and fresh insecurities created by digital tethers/feeling ‘left out’ anxious, even ‘paranoid’ w/technology altering mood/behavior/communication styles (waiting for text/news in the night; updates, etc)

Aside from obvious parenting practices (put the media to sleep too/remove from room) how can kids learn to self-modulate this ‘virtual popularity’ perception, reclaim their rightful roles in their identity quests WITHOUT being tied to what I call the “peers in the pocket” digital drama and relational angst?

Rachel Simmons: I have a workshop I teach where I assign girls different forms of social media (AIM, texting, Facebook photo albums) and ask them to come up with everything they love and can’t stand about each one.

By naming the feelings of insecurity and anxiety that social media can inspire, girls begin to feel more power over what’s happening online. It’s not just something that lives inside of them – and how many girls, indeed how many people, believe it’s only they who feel or are hurt by something – which means girls begin to feel less alone.

 

By the way, it’s just as important for girls to share why they love social media as it is for them to explore what they don’t like. It also helps to learn strategies to manage the strong feelings that can arise online.

If you are aware of your tendency to type your feelings, you can practice calming techniques like walking around the block, petting your dog, or even handing over your phone to a parent or friend.

Finally, it’s actually really useful for girls to embrace the ideas:

‘I am not friends with everyone…

…I cannot be everywhere at once

I will be left out of some events and experiences

…and there may be people who aren’t so into me.’

Social media offers the illusion that you can overcome these social anxieties by letting you text with one person while you hang out with another, or rack up lots of friends. The sooner you realize the impossibility of this – which, hey, let’s face it, isn’t easy — the less in thrall (enslaved)  you will be to your devices.

Amy Jussel, Shaping Youth: Your “Mean Stinks” brand alliance with Secret deodorant on Facebook is an interesting use of social media to ‘put up’ rather than ‘put down’ relational aggression and resolve prior conflicts in mea culpa mode for ‘writing on the wall’ as a ‘social cleanse’ of sorts, like Trudy Ludwig’s “Confessions of a former bully” book…

What ages/stages/gender are adding their voices to the Secret wall? Will you be adding to this social media platform in new ways? Do you use this as a springboard for your Girls Leadership Institute?

Rachel Simmons: I’m very proud to be serve as a spokeswoman for the Mean Stinks initiative. At this point, teen girls are most involved with our platform on Facebook. 

They turn to the wall to seek comfort, provide advice, or seek community. In a recent survey, Secret deodorant found that 87% of young women believe that social media can be used for a positive purpose.

That’s what I love about Mean Stinks. It’s opening a new channel for anti-bullying initiatives, using one of the places that girls most love (Facebook) for prevention and prosocial conduct.

My plan is to continue working with my partner spokeswoman, Amber Riley of Glee, to provide more resources for girls like short videos, Q & A’s, and GirlTips. We’re up to nearly a quarter of a million fans!

Amy Jussel, Shaping Youth: What do you view as the primary impact of  digital relationships on actual physical relationships between people online/day to day friends?

Rachel Simmons: I would say there are two big impacts:

First, friends who hang out together are often texting at the same time.

Most girls I know say they feel ignored and even hurt by this behavior, but they don’t feel like they can say anything.

I think that’s because texting while hanging out has become a social norm among teens. Which is terrible! The behavior is really rude, and I wish we talked more about how it makes others feels, as well as how to stop it.

Second, I think there is an unfair expectation among kids that friendship can be measured in how quickly you respond to someone.

So, if I text you, and you don’t respond RIGHT AWAY, it either means we’re in a fight or you’re not that into me. That’s crazy, but it’s another norm that is evolving. Timing is a very superficial way to measure relationship quality, and it also creates lots of unnecessary drama. As I always say to my students: think about why she hasn’t replied. Maybe she’s busy. Maybe she’s sleeping. Maybe her house is burning down. There are lots of reasons besides you!

Amy Jussel, Shaping Youth: “omg” that happens in my house amping up digital drama in a flash. It’s one of the main behavior exhales I most enjoy in our “digital detox” respites.

Thank you SO much, Rachel for helping us crawl inside girls’ heads for a bit. Very insightful and helpful tips in Odd Girl Out, and in this interview. Oblige!

Another great thing I love about social media sharing is access to digital archives, since I don’t watch much TV. Here’s  Rachel Simmons on the Today Show this morning talking about “what to know before you go” (back to school/social media tips to curb digital abuse)

Visit msnbc.com for breaking news, world news, and news about the economy

Related Reading on Shaping Youth

Textual Harrassment: That’s Not Cool 

Recap of White House Conf on Bullying Summit

Raising Authentic Girls: Be You! The Real Girl Tour (R.Simmons)

Tips for Handling A Real Life Sue Sylvester From Glee (Q&A on Adult Bullies w/RosalindWiseman)

Curse of the Good Girl Interview with Rachel Simmons

Bullying and the Special Needs Child: You Must Be the New Kid

Harris Interactive: How Cyberbullying is Shaping Youth Savvy

Internet Safety: Media Literacy Tips from Industry Insiders Pt 1

Cybersafety Online, Tips from the Inside Out Pt2

Predators=Marketers + Frenemies: Keeping Kids Safe Online

Digital Doings & Teen Docu-Drama Genre/SXSW

Are Game Cheats a Misnomer? Pt 1, digital ethics

Kids, Gaming Ethics & Immersive Virtual Worlds Pt 2

Kids Online Community: Solidarity, Ethics, Getting Rid of Griefers Pt 3

KidLit: Resources Using Children’s Literature to Talk About Bullying

Using Kid Lit To Read the Right Message About Bullying

Great Kid Lit Reading Compilation:  BestChildrensBooks.com

Author Trudy Ludwig’s shortlist (by age) on Rachel Simmons’ blog

Books That Heal Kids blog/bullying

More Personal Picks

Stand Tall, Molly Lou Melon by Patty Lovell (complete w/activities-lesson plan)

Chrysanthemum by Kevin Henkes

Thank You Mr Falker by Patricia Polacco (dyslexia/special needs)

Arthur’s April Fool by Marc Brown

The Berenstain Bears and the Bully by Stan Berenstain

Classics like The Hundred Dresses by Eleanor Estes

Related Resources On Digital Citizenship 

Online Safety 3.0 Empowering & Protecting Youth (Connect Safely)

What is Online “Risk?” Helpful Clarity/Europe (NetFamilyNews)

Cyberbullying “Epidemic?” NO! (NetFamilyNews)

School Bullying: What You Haven’t Heard (Rosalind Wiseman.com)

Formspring: What’s Going On Around It (NetFamilyNews)

Good & Bad Bullying PSAs, How to Tell the Difference (R.Wiseman)Wiseman)

Takeaways From The Bullying Prevention Summit (Anne Collier)

MTV, An Unlikely But Welcomed Voice in The Battle to Protect Youth Online (Internet Safety 101/Enough is Enough Blog)

Major Privacy & Safety Updates At Facebook (NFN)

More Parenting Resources Addressing Digital Conduct

Building Moral Intelligence, by Michele Borba Ed.D and her amazing must-have The Big Book of Parenting Solutions (101 Answers to Your Everyday Challenges and Wildest Worries)

Powerful Words, Dr. Robyn Silverman Shaping Youth advisory board, powerful words character development, author-Good Girls Don’t Get Fat

Oprah’s dialog on bullying, including the Trevor Project, GLSEN.org, HumanRightsCampaign.org and Tolerance.org

HGHW.org (Hardy Girls, Healthy Women)

True Child.org’s great research section on bullying/stereotypes & more

Character Education Read Alouds pre-K/K feelings charts/activities

Rosalind Wiseman.com Creating Cultures of Dignity and her updated version of Queen Bees and Wannabes which Mean Girls was based upon)

Rachel Simmons.com Leadership for Life ( raising confident girls)

Jess Weiner.com Creating a Nation of Confident Women & Girls

Sue Scheff.com author of Google Bomb Book on Reputation Management

New Media Faves:

Adina’s Deck Episodes (using teen dramatizations on film, mysteries of cyberbullying; the online crush, etc.)

Smokescreen Game (U.K. online interactive using social networking as an education tool for media literacy/bullying issues)

A Thin Line.org (MTV’s excellent user-driven peer to peer digital literacy site, full feature forthcoming on prevention of digital abuse/over the line)

That’s Not Cool (Create a speaking avatar, callout cards, sexting intervention, a national public education campaign by Futures Without Violence, Dept. of Justice’s Office on Violence Against Women, and the Advertising Council)

Love Is Not Abuse (quizzes, mobile app, warning signs, e.g.s of unhealthy controlling, pressuring, threatening behavior esp to prevent teen dating/stalking/sexting coercion)

Middle School Confidential (graphic novel series and new iPad app, confidence building, bullying prevention; also see Cruel’s Not Cool Facebook adjunct, AnnieFox.com site, and new digital story for 4-8yo, Are You My Friend? which can be found in the iBooks area for iPads/iPhones.

 

 

404

Comments

  1. This was such a great interview, I’m so happy I found it through Twitter and made time to read it (especially as the mother of two teenage girls). Thanks!

  2. such a great piece of writing!

  3. Thanks Diana for the kudos and for keeping in touch through Twitter where I seem to be more often than not these days! Love your resources will continue to check them out…Thanks!

Speak Your Mind

*

CommentLuv badge